Monday, November 16, 2026 • 07:11 PM
  • Home
  • /
  • Metals Recycling
  • /
  • A Shared Metals Challenge: Reducing Copper Losses and Protecting Steel Scrap Quality
Metals Recycling
Insights

A Shared Metals Challenge: Reducing Copper Losses and Protecting Steel Scrap Quality

By Erin Smith, Deputy Director, EHS and Recycling, Copper Development Association

Post Image

Overview:

  • Copper can become trapped in the steel recycling stream, reducing recoverable copper while creating quality challenges for some steel products.
  • With global copper demand projected to rise 50% by 2040, keeping more copper in productive circulation is becoming increasingly important.
  • Better dismantling, sorting, product design, and emerging separation technologies could help reduce copper losses before the material reaches the steel melt.
  • Progress will require closer collaboration among steel and copper producers, manufacturers, recyclers, and researchers across the full recycling value chain

Copper and steel are foundational materials for modern infrastructure, transportation, energy, and manufacturing. They are also increasingly intertwined at the end of a product’s life.

That relationship presents a recycling challenge that deserves more attention from both industries.

When vehicles, appliances, machinery, and other products containing multiple metals reach the end of their useful lives, they are often shredded for recycling. Copper wiring, motors, and other components can become physically attached to steel fragments during this process. Once copper enters the steel melt, there are currently no commercially viable methods to remove it economically at scale.

Copper and steel can remain physically intertwined after shredding. : Katie Daehn, MIT, and John Lichtenstein, World Steel Dynamics Presentations at the Colorado School of Mines Recycling Metals from Industrial Feedstocks workshop, 2026.

For steelmakers, excessive residual copper can compromise the quality of certain steel products. For the copper industry, those same copper units effectively leave the copper value chain.

Both industries, therefore, have an interest in understanding where these losses occur, how significant they are, and where intervention is technically and economically practical.

A Small Percentage Can Represent a Significant Loss

The challenge becomes more important when viewed against both the scale of material flowing through the recycling system and the amount of copper the global economy is expected to need in the decades ahead.

S&P Global’s 2026 Copper in the Age of AI projects that global copper demand will increase by 50%, from approximately 28 million metric tons in 2025 to 42 million metric tons by 2040. The increase is being driven by core economic demand, the energy transition, the expansion of electrical infrastructure, AI and data centers, and defense modernization. Without meaningful supply expansion, S&P Global projects a potential 10 million metric ton shortfall by 2040.[2]

Source: S&P Global, Copper in the Age of AI: Challenges of Electrification, 2026.

Recycling will play an increasingly important role in meeting that demand. S&P Global projects recycled copper supply from end-of-life scrap could increase from approximately 4 million metric tons in 2025 to about 10 million metric tons by 2040. Even with that significant increase, secondary supply alone will not close the projected gap.

That makes the recovery of copper already circulating through the economy increasingly important.

The automotive recycling system helps illustrate the scale of the opportunity. Approximately 12 million vehicles were recycled by the North American steel scrap industry in 2022. With an estimated 20 to 30 kilograms of copper in a modern vehicle, roughly 300,000 metric tonnes of copper move through the domestic automotive recycling system each year. CDA estimates that copper losses to recycled steel in the United States could be a significant number of metric tonnes annually, somewhere nearing the range of 5% of annual U.S. copper consumption.

Those estimates warrant continued study and validation, but they illustrate why the issue matters. In a market where every viable source of copper will be needed, material losses that may previously have been accepted as an unavoidable consequence of recycling deserve another look.

The Challenge Extends to Steel Quality

Copper entering the steel stream also creates technical constraints for recyclers and steelmakers.

During conventional steelmaking, copper remains in the melt. At sufficiently high concentrations, it can contribute to hot shortness, which causes surface cracking during hot rolling and forming. Different steel products have significantly different copper tolerances. Drawing steels, for example, may require copper concentrations below 0.06% by weight, while reinforcing bar can tolerate concentrations as high as approximately 0.4%.

Steel Grade Maximum Allowable Cu (wt %)

Interstitial Free 0.03

Deep Drawing Quality 0.04

Drawing 0.06

Commercial 0.10

Structural 0.12

Fine Wire 0.07

Rebar 0.40

Source: Huellen, M., Schrade, C., Wilhelm, U., & Zulhan, Z. (2006). EAF-based flat-steel production applying secondary metallurgical processes. Ironmaking Steelmaking Conference, Linz, Austria.

Historically, the steel system has managed these differences by directing higher-copper scrap toward more tolerant applications and diluting recycled material with primary iron.

Research suggests this approach will become increasingly difficult as scrap volumes grow.

A global material-flow analysis led by Katie Daehn, a research scientist at the MIT Climate & Sustainability Consortium, mapped copper concentrations throughout the steel system and compared the amount of copper entering through scrap with the amount various steel products could tolerate. Its best-estimate scenario found that copper contamination could theoretically be managed until approximately 2050, but only with extensive dilution and highly coordinated distribution of scrap to suitable applications. The analysis suggests that more deliberate allocation and dilution would need to begin around 2030.

The 2050 date can therefore be misleading if interpreted as a distant problem. The conditions needed to manage copper in the steel stream become more demanding well before then.

Looking Further Upstream

By the time copper reaches the steel melt, many of the most practical opportunities to recover it have already passed.

Complex products combine steel, copper, aluminum, and other materials. During shredding, those materials are broken apart, but copper pieces can also become mechanically attached to steel. Magnetic and other post-shredding separation technologies recover substantial quantities of material, but they cannot achieve complete separation in every case.[4]

This makes upstream intervention particularly important. Areas that warrant continued research include:

  • Greater removal of copper-containing components before shredding.
  • Improved sensing and sorting technologies, including X-ray fluorescence and laser-based spectroscopy.
  • Physical or chemical processes capable of separating copper from steel scrap.
  • Product designs that make valuable materials easier to separate at the end of life.
  • Standards, incentives, and quality requirements that encourage cleaner scrap preparation.

Researchers have already investigated several of these pathways. Additional dismantling can remove copper-bearing components before shredding, while technologies such as laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy and X-ray fluorescence can help identify copper-rich material for sorting or more strategic batching. Research is also continuing into potential copper extraction processes, although commercial feasibility remains an important question.

A Shared Metals Challenge

No single intervention is likely to solve the problem. Economics, scalability, energy requirements, and the deployment of a technology within the recycling process all matter, and that may be one of the most important conclusions from the work to date.

Different parts of the metals value chain bring different expertise to the problem. 

  • Steelmakers understand the metallurgical limits that determine how scrap can be used.
  • Recyclers understand the realities of dismantling, shredding and sorting.
  • Copper producers understand the implications of losing recoverable units from an increasingly strategic material supply.
  • Manufacturers influence how easily complex products can ultimately be taken apart.
  • Researchers are exploring separation and recovery technologies that could expand what is technically and economically possible.
  • Associations are convening the appropriate stakeholders to drive cross-industry collaboration.

In June 2026, the Copper Development Association (CDA) hosted a workshop titled "Copper Contamination in the Current and Future Steel System: Options for Extraction and Management" at the Colorado School of Mines with experts across academia and the steel and copper value chains. This workshop provided an opportunity to bring together a variety of perspectives, as researchers and industry participants examined the issue of copper contamination in steel systems and potential extraction and management strategies.[4,5]

That type of collaboration needs to continue.

The question is no longer simply how much copper steel can tolerate. We need to understand where copper is being lost, which interventions could incrementally prevent those losses, how incentives can be better aligned across the value chain, and what information the industries still lack.

Policy Should Be Informed By A Full-System Perspective

Policymakers cannot craft effective critical minerals and recycling policy without first understanding how genuinely complex the underlying value chains are, from extraction and processing through manufacturing, use, and end-of-life recovery.

Materials often move through multiple jurisdictions, ownership structures, and processing steps before reaching a recycler, and at each stage, they can pick up trace contaminants that are difficult or impossible to separate out later.

Recognizing this complexity matters because contamination is sometimes an unavoidable byproduct of how a supply chain is currently structured, not a sign of negligence or noncompliance at the recycling stage. For that reason, policymakers should be active participants in industry and technical discussions rather than setting requirements from the outside looking in.

Mandates that require contamination-free outputs at the recycling or end-of-processing stage can become technically infeasible or prohibitively costly given current industrial realities, and may simply push the problem downstream rather than solving it. A more effective approach addresses contamination earlier in the process, at the design, sourcing, or initial processing stages, where interventions are more technically achievable and better matched to how the materials actually behave.

Engaging directly with industry, technical experts, and the realities of each value chain allows policymakers to set standards that are ambitious but grounded, driving real improvement without imposing requirements that the underlying technology and supply chain structure cannot yet support.

Every Recoverable Unit Matters

Meeting future copper demand will require multiple sources of supply.

CDA has advocated for an all-of-the-above copper sourcing strategy for the United States that includes increased domestic mining and refining, expanded recycling, and continued trade with dependable partners. No one pathway can provide all of the copper the economy will require.[5]

Reducing copper losses from end-of-life products is essential. Cleaner scrap benefits the steel industry by allowing for higher-quality recycled steel and reducing the need for dilution to manage copper levels.

There’s an opportunity to deepen our understanding of copper’s movement between the two metal systems and identify how collaboration among copper producers, steelmakers, recyclers, manufacturers, researchers, and policymakers can create impactful changes.

We should act before copper concentrations further constrain steel recycling. As material flows through the system today, recovering more of it requires viewing the recycling chain as an interconnected system, rather than isolated industries.

Sources

1. World Steel Dynamics, “Five Inconvenient Truths About Scrap (Part 2)”, 2026.

2. S&P Global, Copper in the Age of AI: Challenges of Electrification, 2026.

3. Katrin E. Daehn, André Cabrera Serrenho and Julian M. Allwood, “How Will Copper Contamination Constrain Future Global Steel Recycling?” Environmental Science & Technology, Vol. 51, 2017, pp. 6599-6606.

4. Katie Daehn, Copper Contamination in the Current and Future Steel System, and Options for Extraction and Management, Recycling Metals from Industrial Feedstocks, Colorado School of Mines, June 25, 2026.

5. Copper Development Association, Copper Age 2.0, Colorado School of Mines, June 2026. CDA outlines an all-of-the-above U.S. copper sourcing strategy incorporating increased mining and refining, expanded recycling, and continued imports from reliable trading partners.

About the Author: Erin Smith is the Deputy Director of EHS and Recycling at the Copper Development Association. She is an expert in environmental, health, and safety issues within the North American copper value chain, including scrap and recycling. Erin collaborates with regulators, policy groups, scientists, and industry stakeholders to tackle risks and opportunities in copper production and recycling. She leads initiatives that bring together industry leaders and experts to address shared challenges in recycling, circularity, and responsible copper use. With a background as a consulting ecologist, Erin promotes science-based, practical solutions that support sustainability and strong environmental, health, and safety outcomes.


  • By Erin Smith
  • 2026-11-16 15:49:25

Latest News

Serra Verde Begins Rare Earth Shipments to the US, Strengthening Brazil's Role in Global Mineral Supply Metals Processing Solutions
News Image
Metals Mining Consulting

Canadian Institute to Host 25t...

By Editorial Panel, Metals Mining...

News Image
Metals Mining Consulting

Direct Lithium Extraction Xcha...

By Editorial Panel, Metals Mining...

News Image
Metals Mining Consulting

Strengthen Your 2027 Plan with...

By Editorial Panel, Metals Mining...

News Image
Mining Tech

Montana Tech Secures $1 Millio...

By Editorial Panel, Metals Mining...

News Image
Mining Tech

Fieldstone Bio Advances Mining...

By Editorial Panel, Metals Mining...

Metals Mining Business Outlook

At Metals Mining Business Outlook Magazine, we recognize the critical role that the metals and mining industry plays in the global economy. From exploration and extraction to processing and sustainability, our content covers every facet of the industry.